Main Index
Mathematical Analysis
Mathematical Constants
Subject Index
comment on the page
The following beautiful formula was discovered by S.Ramanujan [1] , [2] , [3, Question 289 and Solution, p. 323]
To see the speed of the convergence go to
It appeared as a problem posed by him asking what is value of the left hand side infinite nested continued root. When after several months no answer was supplied, he presented a more general formula
(1) |
To see this note that if denotes the right hand side of (1) then satisfies the functional equation which is solved by . For and we get
(2) |
The solution follows similarly as above from the observation that if denotes the right hand side of (2) then satisfies the functional equation which solution is .
The original Ramanujan’s proof is incomplete. The gaps were filled by Vijayaraghavan [3, p.348] and Herschfeld [4] . The result can also be found in [5] .
For general infinite nested radicals see
[1] | Ramanujan, S. (1911). Question No. 298. Journal of the Indian Mathematical Society, III, 90. |
[2] | Ward, A. (1996). Problem 80.E. The Mathematical Gazette, July, 422. |
[3] | Ramanujan, S. (1927). Collected papers. Edited by G. H. Hardy, P. V. Seshu Aiyar, B. M. Wilson.. Cambridge: University Press. |
[4] | Herschfeld, A. (1935). On infinite radicals. Amer. Math. Monthly , 42, 419-429. |
[5] | Alexanderson, G. L., Klosinski, L. F., & Larson, L. C. (1985). The William Lowell Putnam Mathematical Competition. Problems and solutions: 1965-1984. Washington, D. C.: The Mathematical Association of America. Distr. by John Wiley & Sons. . |
Cite this web-page as:
Štefan Porubský: 3.